I'm super picky about mascara. I like it best when it's a little old and thick, and I like it to go on much like a drag queen probably does. I like my mascara! Consequently, when I find one I like I stick with it forever (or unti it disappears like Max Factor 1000 lashes did). Really, any of the Voluminous line is fine, but I especially like the Carbon Black. I'm not sure it's much different than the regular black, but the name makes it SEEM darker and more, well, slutty, than the regular. Also, I HATE waterproof mascara. Hate the stuff. It doesn't come off and I want all my makeup off my face before bed. I could be completely falling-down drunk (not that that's ever happened before-heh heh) and will still take my makeup off before I
pass out go to sleep. ANYWAY! Sorry about the rant but I really do love this mascara. And I'm nothing if not loyal.